Sign up to stay up to date on the Shelbyville, IN Real Estate Market!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
810 Berkeley Drive 3 1 1,000 $179,900 $179 1 day
562 N Knightstown Road 3 1 1,619 $262,000 $161 2 days
232 W Broadway Street 5 3 6,118 $595,000 $97 4 days
E State Road 44 N/A N/A N/A $49,900 Unknown 5 days
1622 Senior Court 2 2 1,471 $220,000 $149 6 days
205 N Harrison Street N/A N/A N/A $249,999 Unknown 9 days
844 Olmsted Drive 4 3 2,396 $274,000 $114 10 days
1314 Country Creek Circle 3 2 1,611 $239,900 $148 11 days
314 E Pennsylvania Street 2 1 1,144 $159,900 $139 17 days
605 S Miller Street 3 2 2,348 $212,000 $90 17 days
21 W Taylor Street N/A N/A 3,185 $223,500 $70 18 days
130 W Hendricks Street 3 1 2,096 $175,000 $83 20 days
923 Congressional Way 3 2 1,329 $235,000 $176 24 days
2326 Saddle Drive 2 3 2,376 $425,000 $178 22 days
1430 Honeysuckle Drive 6 4 2,729 $357,000 $130 22 days
2375 Larkspur Lane 5 3 2,600 $345,000 $132 24 days
502 W Mechanic Street 2 2 2,406 $214,900 $89 27 days
315 Van Avenue 3 2 3,995 $250,000 $62 30 days
1423 Buttercup Lane 4 3 2,263 $330,000 $145 33 days
755 2nd Street 4 1 1,152 $104,900 $91 46 days
TBD Eastern Avenue N/A N/A N/A $120,000 Unknown 48 days
325 Howard Street 4 2 1,638 $200,000 $122 50 days
2338 William Garrett Way 3 3 2,169 $345,000 $159 52 days
737 Elm Street 3 1 1,518 $90,000 $59 54 days
1837 E Michigan Road N/A N/A 1,800 $650,000 $361 65 days
309 Center Street 3 2 1,368 $138,000 $100 66 days
1041 W Hendricks Avenue 2 1 816 $145,000 $177 69 days
492 W Mechanic Street N/A N/A N/A $25,000 Unknown 67 days
1415 E Michigan Road N/A N/A 4,936 $420,000 $85 68 days
202 W South Street 5 2 2,276 $150,000 $65 71 days
308 Fox Ridge Court 3 2 1,235 $234,900 $190 79 days
1435 Buttercup Lane 4 3 2,463 $344,000 $139 82 days
2335 Larkspur Lane 6 4 2,729 $365,000 $133 85 days
1436 Buttercup Lane 3 2 1,498 $276,500 $184 83 days
1448 Buttercup Lane 4 3 2,463 $334,500 $135 83 days
1022 Spring Hill Road 4 3 5,218 $525,000 $100 90 days
2347 William Garrett Way 3 3 2,577 $349,990 $135 95 days
348 W Locust Street 2 1 1,696 $165,500 $97 95 days
416 Peninsula Drive 2 2 1,748 $374,900 $214 96 days
2343 William Garrett Way 3 3 2,293 $339,990 $148 97 days
2339 William Garrett Way 3 2 1,585 $295,990 $186 97 days
1110 Shelby Street 2 1 868 $100,000 $115 99 days
2410 Valley Road 4 4 5,658 $535,000 $94 114 days
1031 W McKay Road 5 3 2,444 $333,000 $136 116 days
118 E Hendricks Street 4 3 2,229 $329,000 $147 127 days
611 S Harrison Street N/A N/A 2,860 $464,900 $162 158 days
106 W Boggstown Road N/A N/A 4,290 $280,000 $65 202 days
2021 S Riley Highway 5 2 4,240 $425,000 $100 206 days
2021 S Riley Highway N/A N/A 4,240 $425,000 $100 234 days
21 W Pennsylvania Street 5 2 3,104 $265,000 $85 233 days
Average: 3.5 2.3 2,516 $276,981 $130 183 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 63
Viewing 1 - 50 of 63
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
138 2nd Street 2 1 2,032 $179,900 $88 5 days
769 Howard Street 3 1 864 $184,900 $214 8 days
712 Flora Drive 3 2 1,709 $234,900 $137 10 days
1311 Eastern Court 3 2 1,472 $237,000 $161 13 days
1382 Delacorte Circle 4 3 2,600 $279,999 $107 16 days
526 E McKay Road 3 2 1,983 $279,900 $141 18 days
1763 N PR 465 W 3 4 5,139 $699,999 $136 17 days
3050 N Michigan Road 4 3 1,906 $289,900 $152 20 days
737 S West Street 2 1 1,101 $159,900 $145 21 days
1762 S 500 W 2 1 1,664 $164,900 $99 22 days
2701 E Old Rushville Road 4 2 1,645 $239,900 $145 24 days
262-270 E Broadway Street N/A N/A 4,500 $499,000 $110 24 days
925 Delman Drive 3 1 950 $184,900 $194 25 days
107 W Locust Street 3 1 2,763 $160,000 $57 33 days
5650 S 1000 W 3 2 3,296 $375,000 $113 33 days
104 W Locust Street 4 2 1,404 $179,900 $128 34 days
554 W Taylor Street 2 1 1,132 $89,900 $79 37 days
129 1st Street 3 2 2,492 $215,000 $86 47 days
2342 William Garrett Way 3 3 1,995 $309,990 $155 52 days
29 Conrey Street 3 1 1,689 $169,900 $100 57 days
112 4th Street 3 1 2,700 $109,900 $40 59 days
2794 Dylan Drive 4 3 2,683 $385,000 $143 92 days
2438 Winners Circle 5 3 2,701 $460,000 $170 101 days
31 McKenzie Street N/A N/A N/A $17,000 Unknown 102 days
421 W Hendricks Street 3 2 1,200 $194,900 $162 106 days
909 Shelby Street 2 1 2,208 $159,900 $72 116 days
1212 Hickory Drive 3 3 2,200 $315,000 $143 124 days
617 S Tompkins Street 2 1 800 $99,900 $124 131 days
2123 S Fairview Road 3 1 1,440 $189,900 $131 145 days
624 E Timberbrook 3 2 1,425 $229,900 $161 164 days
420 Eastern Avenue N/A N/A 8,200 $499,900 $60 165 days
330 W Broadway Street 3 2 4,914 $280,000 $56 200 days
1430 Preidt Lane 5 3 3,055 $378,500 $123 202 days
42 E Washington Street N/A N/A 11,416 $385,000 $33 214 days
1375 Honeysuckle Drive 5 3 2,600 $327,000 $125 234 days
1306 Delacorte Circle 4 3 2,640 $303,990 $115 261 days
1370 Delacorte Circle 3 3 1,666 $240,000 $144 284 days
2370 Larkspur Lane 4 3 2,275 $314,500 $138 313 days
1155 Breckinridge Way 3 2 1,801 $339,785 $188 360 days
1202 Shelby Street 2 1 1,920 $114,900 $59 416 days
233 E Pennsylvania Street 2 1 2,148 $118,000 $54 419 days
1510 E Mckay Road N/A N/A N/A $345,000 Unknown 1453 days
Average: 3.1 2.0 2,558 $260,541 $120 147 days
Viewing 1 - 42 of 42
Viewing 1 - 42 of 42
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
1020 S West Street 4 2 3,024 $195,000 $197,000 $65 56 days 2/23/24
538 5th Street 3 1 1,488 $167,000 $167,000 $112 85 days 2/23/24
7900 N 250 E N/A N/A N/A $186,500 $156,450 Unknown 205 days 2/22/24
2405 Valley Court 5 5 4,032 $534,900 $526,000 $130 57 days 2/21/24
626 W South Street 3 2 1,611 $160,000 $160,000 $99 45 days 2/20/24
00 Hasecuster Lane N/A N/A N/A $59,900 $30,000 Unknown 362 days 2/20/24
1579 Edgehill Road 3 2 1,442 $215,000 $215,000 $149 31 days 2/16/24
2436 Simpson Lane 3 2 1,498 $225,000 $212,000 $141 84 days 2/13/24
710 Colescott Street 3 1 1,067 $175,000 $170,000 $159 30 days 2/12/24
455 W Hendricks Street 2 1 956 $150,000 $155,000 $162 109 days 2/12/24
2651 E Massengale Road 3 2 2,375 $335,000 $320,000 $134 128 days 2/12/24
1401 S Noble Street 3 2 1,248 $194,900 $185,000 $148 20 days 2/9/24
912 Congressional Way 3 2 1,120 $220,000 $210,000 $187 31 days 2/9/24
2008 Augusta Court 3 2 1,284 $215,000 $216,000 $168 33 days 2/9/24
1545 Aster Drive 4 4 3,108 $377,000 $377,000 $121 35 days 2/9/24
1005 S Tompkins Street 2 1 2,288 $182,000 $173,500 $75 37 days 2/9/24
7160 E 200 N 4 3 2,960 $474,900 $450,000 $152 107 days 2/9/24
156 W Washington Street 4 3 2,455 $390,000 $376,500 $153 205 days 2/9/24
2360 Larkspur Lane 5 3 2,600 $330,000 $327,500 $125 308 days 2/9/24
615 W South Street 2 1 1,004 $79,900 $70,000 $69 26 days 2/5/24
928 Saraina Road 4 3 2,040 $239,900 $232,000 $113 140 days 2/5/24
2325 Larkspur Lane 5 3 2,600 $345,655 $345,655 $132 74 days 2/2/24
207 Fountain Lake Drive S 3 2 1,584 $219,000 $215,000 $135 34 days 1/31/24
1982 N Beechbrook Drive 3 2 1,568 $199,000 $200,000 $127 62 days 1/31/24
1317 S Harrison Street 3 2 1,744 $220,000 $217,000 $124 215 days 1/31/24
2107 Twelve Oaks Drive 3 2 1,210 $215,000 $212,000 $175 55 days 1/30/24
1205 Breckinridge Way 3 2 2,061 $359,995 $364,554 $176 97 days 1/29/24
1203 Cypress Drive 2 2 837 $134,000 $134,000 $160 82 days 1/25/24
117 -119 Howard Street N/A N/A N/A $199,900 $187,500 Unknown 77 days 1/24/24
1159 Breckinridge Way 5 4 3,368 $419,995 $419,995 $124 215 days 1/22/24
116 E Taylor Street 3 2 3,114 $155,000 $147,200 $47 93 days 1/19/24
39 W Washington Street 3 4 5,013 $199,900 $160,000 $31 100 days 1/18/24
310 S Pike Street 2 1 1,237 $68,500 $80,000 $64 70 days 1/17/24
333 W 500N N/A N/A N/A $3,900,000 $3,600,000 Unknown 187 days 1/17/24
109 2nd Street 2 1 2,982 $95,000 $92,500 $31 74 days 1/15/24
26 E Mechanic Street N/A N/A N/A $159,000 $147,000 Unknown 22 days 1/12/24
427 Eastern Avenue 2 2 1,440 $142,900 $135,000 $93 122 days 1/12/24
420 W Taylor Street 2 1 2,324 $135,000 $130,000 $55 153 days 1/10/24
615 W 400 S 3 1 1,792 $245,000 $235,000 $131 84 days 1/8/24
1436 E Lawndale Drive 3 2 1,572 $255,000 $247,000 $157 77 days 1/6/24
671 W 350 N 3 2 2,035 $259,000 $260,000 $127 59 days 1/5/24
1003 S Tompkins Street 3 2 3,120 $180,000 $175,000 $56 28 days 1/4/24
563 W Taylor Street N/A N/A N/A $139,900 $139,000 Unknown 169 days 12/30/23
1151 Breckinridge Way 5 4 4,800 $474,069 $572,768 $119 250 days 12/29/23
1430 E Lawndale Drive 3 2 1,674 $225,000 $215,000 $128 69 days 12/29/23
1203 Stanley Street 3 2 1,232 $195,000 $196,500 $159 42 days 12/22/23
1454 Bontrager Lane 4 2 2,514 $345,000 $345,000 $137 121 days 12/21/23
208 W Hendricks Street 2 2 2,192 $119,900 $125,000 $57 34 days 12/20/23
1013 Crestmoor Drive 3 2 1,120 $184,900 $180,000 $160 35 days 12/20/23
1105 S Noble Street 3 1 1,566 $105,000 $87,500 $55 28 days 12/19/23
Average: 3.1 2.1 2,086 $254,379 $248,631 $123 73 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 159
Viewing 1 - 50 of 159

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2024 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®